This post for cookbook geeks only.
Ferociously smart Eater essay about the Adam Roberts/Mimi Thorisson flap right here. Serious critical intelligence brought to bear on cookbooks. I wish I’d written it, or even thought it.
Ferociously smart Eater essay about the Adam Roberts/Mimi Thorisson flap right here. Serious critical intelligence brought to bear on cookbooks. I wish I’d written it, or even thought it.
And this offers a different perspective on the dispute, lamenting how boring, homogeneous, and uncritical most cooking blogs are and how insular the food community.
Now, to the Piglet.
Thanks to John T. Edge’s rhapsodic Piglet review the other day, I bought Smashing Plates, an attractive 200-page collection of Greek recipes by Maria Elia, a British chef of Cypriot heritage. Although I haven’t cooked anything from it yet, I like what I see, starting with honeyed fried feta and some kalamata olive gnocchi. The desserts are especially fetching, which I didn’t expect from a Greek cookbook. Curious about the orange and fennel seed ice cream and the almond, rosewater, and chocolate Mallomar chimneys. I’m hoping this book blows me away because I’m not 100% satisfied with the other candidates to win the Piglet, now down to David Lebovitz’s Paris Kitchen and Brooks Headley’s Fancy Desserts.
We’ve been dining almost exclusively from David L. lately, and dining well. Multigrain bread, tarte tropezienne, lamb tagine, caramel ribs, butternut squash panade, lemon-pistachio couscous. The last two dishes on that list are my favorites, but all have been strong. I really, really, really like this book, but it’s The King’s Speech of cookbooks -- impeccably executed, intelligent, enjoyable, unsurprising. My Paris Kitchen could definitely win the big prize and there’s an argument to be made on its behalf, but you won’t hear it from me. It’s far from the most interesting cookbook of 2014.
Fancy Desserts, meanwhile, is without doubt one of the most interesting cookbooks of 2014. Ed Lee served up a powerhouse Piglet review the other day. Ok, it’s a little purple, but I like the energy:
"All of these desserts will alter the rest of your life, if you have the patience to make them. They’re that good. Fancy Desserts, with its recipes connected like a mystery novel, can be confusing, illogical, hilarious, disarming, vulnerable, and intimidating -- and I could not put it down. Part culinary manifesto, part punk rock tapestry, part New York City folklore, this book is not just a fascinating read, it’s a portrait of a person, of a time, and of a place so unique you feel lucky to live it through the pages of a book. I wish more chefs were this honest about themselves. Hell, I wish more people were too.
What I will say is this: Don’t attempt to make a recipe until you’ve read the whole book -- every page, cover to cover. . . ."
All of these desserts will alter the rest of your life? All of them? Even the borrowed Good to the Grain chocolate chip cookies reprinted with a fatal mistake?
Whatever. Enthusiasm is nice.
I’ve made a handful of Headley’s recipes, two of them really splendid. I already wrote about the ricotta gelato (super-easy recipe here) and last week tried his cashew gelato, which was the most velvety ice cream ever scooped out of my machine. It was just as creamy the next night and the next and I don’t know about the next because by then it was gone. To make this magical dessert, you roast raw cashews until coffee brown and steep in milk overnight. Remove cashews from milk, combine infused milk with sugar, dextrose powder, honey, milk powder, condensed milk, cream, and raw egg yolks. Blend. Chill. Churn. It’s not going to alter the rest of my life, but it was stupendously delicious.
"All of these desserts will alter the rest of your life, if you have the patience to make them. They’re that good. Fancy Desserts, with its recipes connected like a mystery novel, can be confusing, illogical, hilarious, disarming, vulnerable, and intimidating -- and I could not put it down. Part culinary manifesto, part punk rock tapestry, part New York City folklore, this book is not just a fascinating read, it’s a portrait of a person, of a time, and of a place so unique you feel lucky to live it through the pages of a book. I wish more chefs were this honest about themselves. Hell, I wish more people were too.
What I will say is this: Don’t attempt to make a recipe until you’ve read the whole book -- every page, cover to cover. . . ."
All of these desserts will alter the rest of your life? All of them? Even the borrowed Good to the Grain chocolate chip cookies reprinted with a fatal mistake?
Whatever. Enthusiasm is nice.
I’ve made a handful of Headley’s recipes, two of them really splendid. I already wrote about the ricotta gelato (super-easy recipe here) and last week tried his cashew gelato, which was the most velvety ice cream ever scooped out of my machine. It was just as creamy the next night and the next and I don’t know about the next because by then it was gone. To make this magical dessert, you roast raw cashews until coffee brown and steep in milk overnight. Remove cashews from milk, combine infused milk with sugar, dextrose powder, honey, milk powder, condensed milk, cream, and raw egg yolks. Blend. Chill. Churn. It’s not going to alter the rest of my life, but it was stupendously delicious.
So what’s wrong with Headley’s book? Nothing, there’s just not enough stuff I want to try here. I don’t want to taste the yeast, sage, parsley, or basil gelatos. I’ll never make the corn-corn huckleberry cookie or the chocolate eggplant confection, sweet pea cake, candied carrots or even that cucumber creamsicle both Lee and Adam Roberts so loved. No interest in the sunchoke or artichoke desserts, nor the strawberries in a pool of avocado puree. I’m sure it’s all wonderful, but I still don’t want to make it.
Maybe that says more about me than it does the book. Maybe Fancy Desserts should win. I’m just saying I personally have trouble getting behind it.
The exciting cookbook I don’t want to cook from vs. the semi-boring cookbook I can’t stop cooking from. This is why I have my hopes pinned on Smashing Plates.
****
Maybe that says more about me than it does the book. Maybe Fancy Desserts should win. I’m just saying I personally have trouble getting behind it.
The exciting cookbook I don’t want to cook from vs. the semi-boring cookbook I can’t stop cooking from. This is why I have my hopes pinned on Smashing Plates.
****
A few final words about Mimi Thorisson’s Kitchen in France: it’s very good and I had almost universal success with the recipes. Her garlic soup is delicious, creamy, and simple. The apple tart with orange flower water is tasty, though a bit severe and not something I’d make again. The almond mussels, as I’ve told you, are a knockout. The galette Perougienne is a lovely, bready, rustic dessert, the pear flognarde, a lovely, custardy, rustic dessert. The cocoa meringues worked perfectly and the chicken with creme fraiche was a treat.
There’s some funkiness with her volume-weight conversions, especially when it comes to butter. The recipe for Sarah Bernhardt cakes (very seductive-looking Icelandic cookies) calls for 10 tablespoons//300 g butter. Clearly a mistake, as 10 tablespoons butter = 141 grams. I happened to make Thorisson’s gougeres and her almond mussels for the same meal one night and noticed that while both call for 7 tablespoons of butter, for the gougeres she offers a weight measurement of 80 g and for the mussels 100 g. I spent a few minutes going through the book and in different recipes a tablespoon of butter is weighted at 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, and 17 grams. This isn’t a big deal when you’re talking about a couple of tablespoons, but the disparities add up. For instance, in one tart dough Thorisson calls for 14 tablespoons//150 grams of butter. The difference between 14 tablespoons and 150 grams of butter is almost half a stick. Adding a half stick more of butter, or a half stick less, will significantly change a tart dough.
Is this a grave matter? No. All the recipes I made worked, most look sound, and mistakes happen. To any stray Mimi fans who might stumble over here and accuse me of being a frumpy jealous hater for pointing out these errors, put down your flamethrowers. Maybe frumpy, but not jealous, not a hater. I thoroughly enjoyed Mimi Thorisson’s Kitchen in France, will make her mussels again and again, and would recommend the book without hesitation.
On another subject, I’d never heard of cruffins, but now I have and need to plan a field trip.
On another subject, I’d never heard of cruffins, but now I have and need to plan a field trip.
That Eater essay is brilliant - thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteI know. So, so smart.
DeleteThanks for pointing out that essay, it really nails what was bothering me about the whole kerfuffle.
ReplyDeleteAlso, the cruffin kind of sounds like a morning bun with filling. You have to investigate!
I will have a cruffin within the week.
DeleteI know it generated controversy, but I enjoyed your summation of MT's book in your previous post and your discussion of the images. I hope the results won't stop you from your frank and highly readable reviews in the future.
ReplyDeleteCookbook editing is, in my opinion, becoming increasingly poor, as is testing of recipes, as the pace of publication picks up. A copyeditor should have picked up those errors, if the author hadn't.
I checked my math 15 times on those conversions and still worry I made a mistake. It's so easy for little glitches to get through in a cookbook -- I don't fault Thorisson for that.
DeleteThat was a very well written essay. Did you see that Adam Roberts felt the need to add a comment.
ReplyDeleteWith the conversion errors, would you be more inclined to believe the gram measurements?
I saw that! And I found it super annoying (esp. because he still doesn't seem to get it!)
DeleteI did see Roberts' comment. I was thinking the grams would be more reliable. Don't the French use scales? So the conversions would have been to tablespoons, not the other way.
DeleteI once made sticky buns with croissant dough, and they didn't turn out well. They puffed up high but then collapsed. The cruffins look really good, though.
ReplyDeleteI think Mimi was unwise to have responded at all to the review. The more I've read of her blog, the more I like her, but it seemed childish and ungracious to protest the review. She labored the point of how unlikely her husband thought she would be to win, which seemed disingenuous. I haven't seen her book in person, but I find those glamor shots embarrassing. I think they look like Anthropologie photo shoots. I'm trying to put my finger on why that seems inappropriate.
The cashew ice cream sounds so good. I have no desire to make the yeast ice cream, but could you explain it to me, just so I can wrap my brain around it? I once had some fresh yeast that had been frozen and thawed, and was therefore kind of fluid, and the chef came by and, thinking it was peanut butter, dipped her finger into it and stuck a huge blob of it in her mouth. Oh, boy, she'll never forget that awful moment.
I will make the yeast ice cream, just so I can tell you about it.
DeleteI made a Breton butter cake, btw -- recipe from Prune. Thought of you. She puts orange flower water in hers and it is INCREDIBLE.
I just bought Fancy Desserts and Smashing Plates. I also got a used copy of Jane Grigson's Good Things-- do you like her? I only have her Fish book and I'm pretty shocked at how interesting she can make the subject matter. I agree regarding that Eater essay. I'm just annoyed that Amateur Gourmet is being taken this seriously.
ReplyDeleteJane Grigson is so charming! I love her. I've made some dishes from Good Things. I think there's a carrot soup in there with a lot of thyme. I'll have to go look at my copy and see what else I made.
DeleteI'm still laughing at this comment from ma Food52 reader:
ReplyDelete"I enjoyed the review but it made me want to buy Flavor Flour. I'd be content to be a worse person making foolproof and delicious desserts."
ha ha ha. I get it!
DeleteCan I just say that this single entry of yours as a stand-alone piece (not to mention the last few weeks' entries) is a far more comprehensive review of all the books than any one of the reviews in the Piglet? I don't mean to carry on with the Piglet saga or to malign it, because I really have enjoyed it this year, particularly given the controversy and all of it's ensuing ramifications. I really say all this to point out that there is truly excellent stuff here and your opinions are always entertaining and enlightening, even when I disagree with them.
ReplyDeleteI hadn't thought of myself as a cookbook geek but apparently I am. So be it.
Thanks, Maggie! I thought on the whole the judges were really good this year. And though it wasn't always pretty, the controversy led to some interesting discussions.
DeleteThank you for those links!! I liked both articles, especially the Eater.com one. What drove me nuts, and it looks like lolcatgirl already pointed it out, is why in the Adam Roberts would respond? I was on his sides (as much as taking sides in an online food blogger battle exists...) until then.
ReplyDeleteThe truth about sexism is, that even if your intentions are honest and you did not mean to sound sexist, a comment, an essay, a comic can be sexist. And Helen Rosner does a good job outlining how Roberts was, in fact, however unintentionally, sexist. By chiming in, Roberts suddenly become more defensive and more childish in my eyes.
Which makes me want to force him to read lottie and doof's essay and to yell that criticism is great. Learn how to look at it and take what you can from it. The moment you are defensive is the moment that you have lost.
Ok, rant over. Thanks again for the links!
Yes, my view of the situation and players kept changing, too, much as yours did.
DeleteRegarding your comment about conversions: I bought the British version of Nigella Lawson's Domestic Goddess and compared it to the American version. The recipes in the British version worked, the American versions were iffy. Whoever does the conversions (probably not the authors) can make mistakes (who doesn't?), and I bet the American versions are not independently tested.
ReplyDeleteI sought out the British version of Domestic Goddess as well after throngs of people using the U.S. version complained of inaccuracies. I also bought the U.K. version of Dan Lepard's Short & Sweet (my favorite baking tome) to have weight instead of volume measurements. More expensive for sure, but well worth it.
DeleteI've become a complete convert (ha) to weight measurements, which is why I notice when there's a problem now. (I also have the British Dan Lepard, we're on the same page about him, HC.) It's so easy for these mistakes to happen -- but it would also be easy to catch them. I stumbled across a few mistakes in Thorisson and then just flipping through the book looking for more, found them. Quickly. In a matter of 15 minutes. Yesterday I started making the yeast gelato from Piglet-winner Brooks Headley's book and came across a conversion error there. The second error I've encountered while actually cooking from his book. You can't chalk the Fancy Desserts errors up to international confusion. Based on my experience thus far, the recipes are sloppy.
Deletelos angeles clippers jerseys
ReplyDeletenike store
dallas cowboys jersey
chelsea jersey
ray ban outlet
dwyane wade jersey
air jordan shoes
nike huarache
nike trainers
nike free uk
eagles jerseys
mulberry outlet
prada outlet
evening dresses
kate spade sale
cheap wedding dresses
new york knicks jersey
tim duncan jersey
true religion sale
cleveland cavaliers jersey
swarovski uk
michael kors outlet
toms shoes outlet online
manchester united jersey
michael kors handbags,michael kors outlet,michael kors outlet online,michael kors,kors outlet,michael kors outlet online sale,michael kors handbags clearance,michael kors purses,michaelkors.com,michael kors bags,michael kors shoes,michaelkors,cheap michael kors
stuart weitzman sale
nike free run
mizuno running shoes
kate spade outlet
air jordan shoes
yongri0716
oakley outlet store
ReplyDeleteadidas wings shoes
canada goose jackets
true religion outlet
coach outlet online
ray ban sunglasses
tory burch outlet online
nobis jacket
mizuno running shoes
beats by dre
cheap ray ban sunglasses
tods outlet
canada goose jackets
ghd uk
chanel handbags outlet
snapbacks wholesale
cheap nike shoes
michael kors uk
nba jerseys
air force 1 shoes
11118minko
cheap salomon shoes
ReplyDeleteburberry outlet online
North Face Sale
nike factory store
replica rolex watches
abercrombie and fitch outlet store
marc jacobs outlet
jordan 14
coach factory online
puma outlet
new balance running shoes
coach handbags
nike shoes
coach outlet
North Face Outlet Locations
coach factory store online
cheap coach purses
cheap jordans
converse shoes sale
cheap canada goose
jordan shoes
christian louboutin shoes
cheap converse shoes
nike shoes
mont blanc pens
Michael Kors
nike air max
abercrombie outlet online
converse sale clearance
kate spade outlet
coach sale
michael kors outlet handbags
cheap michael kors handbags
clarks shoes clearance
prada outlet
dior outlet online
coach factory outlet
coach wallet
air jordan 13 retro
cheap michael kors handbags
ferragamo outlet online
cheap nike air max
hollister clothing store online
north face outlet store
michael kors handbags
polo shirts for men
qwe1.7
happy diwali sms
ReplyDeletehappy diwali
diwali images
happy new year 2017
new year shayari
new year images
happy navratri
independence day sms
raksha bandhan sms
online sbi personal banking
happy birthday wishes
free web hosting
pnb net banking activation
sol result
metro card recharge
sbi login
ReplyDeleteKannur University Result 2016 for all course
ReplyDeleteKannur University Admit Card 2016
Kannur University Hall Ticket 2017
Kannur University Result 2017
Kannur University Admit Card 2016
Kannur University Entrance Date 2016
Kannur University Degree Allotment
Kannur University Trial Allotment 2016
Kannur University Admission 2016
Kannur University Onlie Admission
Kannur University Distance Education Result 2016
Kannur University Hall Ticket 2016
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University BA Result 2016-2017
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Hall Ticket 2016
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Result 2016 for all course
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Admit Card 2016
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Hall Ticket 2017
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Result 2017
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Admit Card 2016
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Entrance Date 2016
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Degree Allotment
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Trial Allotment 2016
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Admission 2016
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Onlie Admission
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Distance Education Result 2016
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Open University Hall Ticket 2016
Karnatak State Open University BA Result 2016-2017
Karnatak State Open University Hall Ticket 2016
Karnatak State Open University Result 2016 for all course
Karnatak State Open University Admit Card 2016
Karnatak State Open University Hall Ticket 2017
Karnatak State Open University Result 2017
Karnatak State Open University Admit Card 2016
Karnatak State Open University Entrance Date 2016
Karnatak State Open University Degree Allotment
Karnatak State Open University Trial Allotment 2016
Karnatak State Open University Admission 2016
Karnatak State Open University Onlie Admission
ReplyDeleteKarnatak State Open University Distance Education Result 2016
Karnatak State Open University Hall Ticket 2016
Andhara University BA Result 2016-2017
Andhara University Hall Ticket 2016
Andhara University Result 2016 for all course
Andhara University Admit Card 2016
Andhara University Hall Ticket 2017
Andhara University Result 2017
Andhara University Admit Card 2016
Andhara University Entrance Date 2016
Andhara University Degree Allotment
Andhara University Trial Allotment 2016
Andhara University Admission 2016
Andhara University Onlie Admission
Andhara University Distance Education Result 2016
Andhara University Hall Ticket 2016
Symbiosis University BA Result 2016-2017
Symbiosis University Hall Ticket 2016
Symbiosis University Result 2016 for all course
Symbiosis University Admit Card 2016
Symbiosis University Hall Ticket 2017
Symbiosis University Result 2017
Symbiosis University Admit Card 2016
Symbiosis University Entrance Date 2016
Symbiosis University Degree Allotment
Symbiosis University Trial Allotment 2016
Symbiosis University Admission 2016
Symbiosis University Onlie Admission
Symbiosis University Distance Education Result 2016
Symbiosis University Hall Ticket 2016
IBS Hydrabad BA Result 2016-2017
IBS Hydrabad Hall Ticket 2016
IBS Hydrabad Result 2016 for all course
IBS Hydrabad Admit Card 2016
IBS Hydrabad Hall Ticket 2017
IBS Hydrabad Result 2017
IBS Hydrabad Admit Card 2016
IBS Hydrabad Entrance Date 2016
IBS Hydrabad Degree Allotment
Happy New Year 2017 SMS
ReplyDeleteHappy New Year 2017 Wishes
Happy New Year 2017 Greeting Cards
Happy New Year 2017 Messages
Happy New Year 2017 Shayari
Happy New Year 2017 Email Template
Happy New Year 2017 Horoscope
Happy New Year 2017 HD Wallpaper
Happy New Year 2017 Images
Happy New Year 2017 Qoutes
Happy New Year 2017 Calendar
Happy New Year 2017 Vector
Happy New Year 2017 Clipart
Happy New Year 2017 whatsapp Images & Messages
online pan card application for nri
ReplyDeleteonline pan card apply
online pan card status
online pan card print
online pan card correction
online pan card copy
online pan card application form download
online pan card details
online Pan Card Verification
How to change photo on pan card
How to get tax return status
How to get duplicate pan crad
how to get nri pan card
Online nri pan card
Online get nri pan card
Online change photo on pan card
Online tax return status
Online duplicate pan card
Bank of india
ReplyDeleteHow to Activate bank of india internet baqnking online
Bank Of India Online Mobile Banking
Apply Online BOI Vehicle Loan
BAnk of India Credit Card
Apply Online jobs In Bank of India
Prdhan mantri jan Dhan Yojana Scheme
Bank of india Agri Clinic Loan
Bank Of India Education Loaqn
Bank Of India Star Smart Home Loan
Bank of india Loan Against Property
ghd flat iron
ReplyDeleteoakley sunglasses
green bay packers jerseys
jordan shoes
ecco shoes
valentino shoes
jimmy choo shoes
seahawks jersey
ghd hair straighteners
skechers shoes
tiffany and co outlet
ReplyDeleterolex watches uk
adidas yeezy
rolex replica watches
yeezy boost 350
fred perry
nike air max
ugg outlet
ralph lauren outlet
coach outlet
20170110
EPFO
ReplyDeleteepf Balance
epf online Claim
epf account balance check
epf account login
UAN Activation
epf status
Obat Aborsi,, Obat Penggugur Kandungan,,
ReplyDeleteNice bag you can earn money from that
Thanks for your posting
Visit me @, Jual Obat Aborsi,,
nice post friend , Thank you for sharing with us, and we sincerely hope you will continue to update or post other articles
ReplyDeletecara menghentikan flek coklat berkepanjangan yang keluar setelah haid
canada goose outlet
ReplyDeletechristian louboutin
salomon boots
coach outlet
ralph lauren outlet
mbt shoes
asics sneakers
adidas outlet store
nike blazer low
air jordan shoes
curry 7
ReplyDeletehermes
hermes online
kyrie spongebob
yeezy boost
supreme clothing
air jordan
kd shoes
supreme clothing
bape
navigate to this site Fendi Dolabuy visit here Bottega Veneta Dolabuy our website www.dolabuy.ru
ReplyDelete